blue color tone of close up rain water drop falling to the floor

(Credit: © กรบุรษ วรดี - stock.adobe.com)

Murcia’s Church Prayed Late in Droughts, When Rain Was Already Likely

In A Nutshell

  • In church records from Murcia, Spain, dated 1600 to 1836, rain was 71% more likely to be recorded within a month of a prayer for rain, though daily odds stayed low.
  • Weather, not magic, is the likely reason: in some places, rain grows likelier the longer a drought lasts, so late prayers look successful.
  • Across more than 1,200 ethnic groups, rain rituals were 47% more common where rain odds climb during droughts.
  • Farming societies, especially those with intensive irrigation, were also more likely to pray for rain.

In Murcia, Spain, records from 1600 to 1836 show a Catholic church praying for rain during droughts, and on any day within a month of a prayer, rain was 71% more likely to be recorded. That did not mean the prayers worked. The church tended to pray when rain was already due, according to a new study. Call it math, not magic.

Researchers behind the work say the trick lies in how weather behaves. In some places, the chance of rain creeps up the longer a drought drags on. A prayer timed to that stretch is more likely to look successful, even though it never caused a single drop. Murcia’s climate happens to work exactly that way.

Worldwide records pointed in the same direction. Among more than 1,200 ethnic groups, those living with this kind of weather were far more likely to have a tradition of praying for rain. The findings appear in The Quarterly Journal of Economics, and they help explain why such rituals keep going for centuries.

Prayers for Rain Look Effective When Droughts Raise the Odds

In the researchers’ thinking, a religious leader wants people to believe prayer brings rain but cannot control the weather. Success comes down to luck and timing. Where rain is equally likely on any given day, prayer offers no edge, since it rains just as often when nobody prays. Nobody is fooled for long.

Some climates play along. After a rainy spell, Murcia’s odds of more rain shrink, bottom out about two months into a dry stretch, and then climb until they roughly double. A leader who waits until a drought has dragged on to start praying will see rain grow more likely just as the prayers begin. Prayers also kept going until rain arrived, so no one ever saw how a long drought might have ended without them. Over generations, that steady string of apparent wins builds belief, even though the leader controlled nothing. The logic resembles waiting for an overdue bus. The longer the wait, the likelier it arrives, and anyone who started waving just before it showed up would look like a bus whisperer.

Why Rain Prayers Seem to Work
A new study of 237 years of Murcia church records finds prayers for rain came when rain was already likely to arrive. (Image by StudyFinds)

Murcia Church Prayers for Rain Were Followed by Higher Rainfall Odds

To test the idea, the team turned to Murcia, a city where the Catholic church has held official prayers for rain since at least the 1300s. As droughts dragged on, the prayers escalated from a special mass to public processions carrying holy relics through the streets. Researchers matched daily church records of prayers from 1600 to 1836 against town council minutes logging standout rainfall, which the council kept separately from the church.

That 71% jump comes with a catch: daily odds start small, rising from roughly 0.2% on an ordinary day to about 0.35% after a prayer. The link held within each month of the year, so the church was not merely praying as rainy season approached. After the church lost its ability to collect taxes in 1837 and prayed far less, recorded rainfall stayed the same, which argues against the council padding rain reports to please the church.

Rain Rituals Show Up More Often Where Rain Odds Climb During Droughts

One city proves little, so the team built a worldwide data set from 370 anthropological sources, recording whether 1,208 ethnic groups traditionally held rain rituals. About 39% did, from the Cherokee rain dance to a Herero ceremony in Namibia involving a calf sprinkled with water. In Shandong, China, a magistrate around the year 951 caned a clay dragon after it failed to deliver rain, and rain reportedly fell that same day.

Each group was matched to the weather where its ancestors lived. Among groups in places where rain odds do not climb during droughts, about 30% held rain rituals. Where the odds do climb, about 44% did, a 47% jump that held up after accounting for climate and geography. Once that pattern was counted, neither dryness, unpredictable weather, nor longer droughts added anything. What counted was the rise in rain odds, and only for dry spells that began during the growing season, when crops needed water most.

Farming Societies Hold Rain Rituals More Often

Farming mattered too. Groups that depended on agriculture were more likely to pray for rain, and the pull was strongest among those with intensive irrigated farming, whose rate of rain rituals was more than double the 32% found among groups that did not depend on farming. Irrigation offered no escape from the sky. Murcia’s canals were fed by rain, and farmers tied to fixed fields cannot move when rain fails.

None of this shows that prayer causes rain, and the study never tested faith itself. It looked at why the tradition of praying for rain takes hold, and the researchers’ answer is that some climates keep handing believers evidence. The worldwide link is a pattern, not proof of cause, but the Murcia records show how that evidence piles up. Prayers for rain survive where the weather keeps backing them up.


Disclaimer: This article summarizes findings from a published research paper and is intended for general information only. The study’s results describe patterns in historical records and may not apply to every situation. For full details, consult the original paper.


Paper Notes

Limitations

Murcia’s case study covers one city and one religious institution across more than two centuries, and the authors note it may reflect the habits of a single sophisticated church rather than a universal pattern. Rainfall records for that period came from town council minutes that recorded only standout rainfall events rather than complete daily measurements, since daily rainfall records for Murcia only became available in the mid-nineteenth century. For the global data set, the authors relied on anthropological accounts recorded mostly between 1850 and 1950, matched each group to modern weather station data, and coded a group as lacking a rain ritual when no clear evidence turned up, so some groups without a recorded ritual may simply lack documentation. The worldwide findings are observational, showing that rain rituals and the climbing-odds weather pattern go together rather than proving the pattern caused each tradition. The study also tests an explanation for why prayers can appear effective. It does not test whether prayer has any supernatural influence over the weather.

Funding and Disclosures

Grant support came from FLOODMED (PID2024-157662OB-C22), funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science, Innovation and Universities and by the European Regional Development Fund (ERDF/EU), according to the authors’ acknowledgments. They also thank research assistants for help with the project and seminar participants at many universities and conferences for comments. No competing interests are listed in the paper’s text.

Publication Details

“Praying for Rain” was written by José-Antonio Espín-Sánchez (Yale University), Salvador Gil-Guirado (University of Murcia), and Nicholas Ryan (Yale University). It was published in The Quarterly Journal of Economics (2026), volume 141, issue 3, pages 2363 to 2422, by Oxford University Press on behalf of the President and Fellows of Harvard College, with advance access publication on May 11, 2026. The article is open access under a Creative Commons Attribution license. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/qje/qjag026. Replication data are available through Harvard Dataverse at https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/H4WS7U.

About StudyFinds Analysis

Called "brilliant," "fantastic," and "spot on" by scientists and researchers, our acclaimed StudyFinds Analysis articles are created using an exclusive AI-based model with complete human oversight by the StudyFinds Editorial Team. For these articles, we use an unparalleled LLM process across multiple systems to analyze entire journal papers, extract data, and create accurate, accessible content. Our writing and editing team proofreads and polishes each and every article before publishing. With recent studies showing that artificial intelligence can interpret scientific research as well as (or even better) than field experts and specialists, StudyFinds was among the earliest to adopt and test this technology before approving its widespread use on our site. We stand by our practice and continuously update our processes to ensure the very highest level of accuracy. Read our AI Policy (link below) for more information.

Our Editorial Process

StudyFinds publishes digestible, agenda-free, transparent research summaries that are intended to inform the reader as well as stir civil, educated debate. We do not agree nor disagree with any of the studies we post, rather, we encourage our readers to debate the veracity of the findings themselves. All articles published on StudyFinds are vetted by our editors prior to publication and include links back to the source or corresponding journal article, if possible.

Our Editorial Team

Steve Fink

Editor-in-Chief

John Anderer

Associate Editor