Material

Three polycatenated architected materials printed out in three different materials: nylon, TPU (thermoplastic polyurethane), and steel. (Credit: Wenjie Zhou)

In a nutshell

  • Scientists have created revolutionary materials that can switch between liquid-like and solid-like states on demand, potentially transforming everything from protective gear to medical devices
  • These materials maintain their unique properties whether they’re the size of a golf ball or smaller than a human hair, making them valuable for both large-scale and microscopic applications
  • The materials can rapidly respond to electrical charges, offering promising applications in robotics, adaptive medical devices, and protective equipment that becomes rigid only when needed

PASADENA, Calif. — The line between solid and liquid just got a lot blurrier. Scientists at the California Institute of Technology have engineered materials that can transition between flowing like water and becoming rigid as plastic, potentially revolutionizing everything from protective gear to medical devices. These materials, which can also respond to electrical charges and absorb impacts, represent a fundamental shift in how we think about matter.

Most materials we encounter in daily life are either consistently solid (like a wooden table) or liquid (like water). But these new materials, called polycatenated architected materials, or PAMs for short, blur that line. They’re made up of rings or cage-like structures that interlock like pieces of a 3D puzzle, allowing them to move and slide against each other until they lock into place when enough force is applied.

The research, published in Science, draws inspiration from an unexpected source: medieval chain mail armor. While chain mail is made of simple metal rings linked together to form a protective mesh, these new materials take the ancient concept to new heights.

“With PAMs, the individual particles are linked as they are in crystalline structures, and yet, because these particles are free to move relative to one another, they flow, they slide on top of each other, and they change their relative positions, more like grains of sand,” says study author Chiara Daraio, a professor at Caltech, in a statement.

The research began with Wenjie Zhou, a former chemist turned postdoctoral researcher in Daraio’s lab. The team created their initial designs using computer modeling, translating crystal lattice patterns into structures where the fixed particles were replaced by interlocked rings or multi-sided cages. These designs were then 3D printed using various materials, including acrylic polymers, nylon, and metals, resulting in prototype cubes and spheres about two inches across. To test their creations, the researchers subjected them to various types of stress.

Chainmail material
Experiments from the Caltech lab of Chiara Daraio have yielded a fascinating new type of matter, neither granular nor crystalline, that responds to some stresses as a fluid would and to others like a solid. The new material, known as PAM (for polycatenated architected materials) could have uses in areas ranging from helmets and other protective gear to biomedical devices and robotics. This image shows how a PAM looks in its fluid or granular state, conforming to the shape of the vessel in which it is held. (Credit: Wenjie Zhou)

“We started with compression, compressing the objects a bit harder each time,” says Zhou. “Then we tried a simple shear, a lateral force, like what you would apply if you were trying to tear the material apart. Finally, we did rheology tests, seeing how the materials responded to twisting, first slowly and then more quickly and strongly.”

When subjected to certain forces, the materials showed almost no resistance, similar to how water flows. Under other conditions, they would suddenly become rigid and strong. This dual personality makes them unique among engineered materials and opens up possibilities for numerous applications.

“PAMs can be very different from one another,” explains Daraio. “You can print them in squishy materials or hard ones. You can change the shape of each particle, and you can change the lattice that you use to connect these particles. Each of these parameters affects the behavior of the resulting material.”

What makes these materials particularly revolutionary is their scalability. While most materials behave differently at different sizes—think of how a large sheet of paper falls compared to a tiny piece of confetti—PAMs maintain their core properties whether they’re the size of a golf ball or smaller than a human hair. This consistency across scales is rare in materials science and makes PAMs especially valuable for engineering applications.

PAM
This PAM, in its granular state, takes the shape of a drop of water or honey. (Credit:
Wenjie Zhou)

The microscopic versions of these materials point toward perhaps the most exciting future applications. At this scale, individual building blocks are about the size of a human blood cell, allowing for potentially revolutionary medical applications. These tiny structures could be used to create devices that navigate through the body’s narrowest passages, changing shape as needed to deliver medications or perform minimally invasive procedures.

Another promising application lies in protective gear. Current technologies often force a trade-off between comfort and safety. Motorcycle jackets, for example, typically use rigid armor inserts that can be uncomfortable during normal wear. PAMs could create gear that remains flexible and comfortable during regular use but instantly stiffens upon impact, providing better protection when needed.

The research could also apply to robotics. Traditional robots often rely on rigid components connected by joints, limiting their flexibility and adaptability. Materials that can transition between fluid-like and solid-like states could lead to robots that can flow through tight spaces like a liquid but solidify to perform tasks requiring strength and precision.

“We can envision incorporating advanced artificial intelligence techniques to accelerate the exploration of this vast design space. We are only scratching the surface of what is possible,” says study author Liuchi Li, now an assistant professor at Princeton University.

The development of PAMs represents what Daraio calls “a fascinating frontier that promises to redefine what materials are and how they behave.” Their work bridges a gap in materials science between granular materials and elastic deformable materials, creating something entirely new that combines properties of both.

As researchers continue to explore the possibilities of these materials, the applications seem limited only by imagination. From protective gear that adapts to impacts to medical devices that navigate through blood vessels, PAMs represent not just a new material but a new way of thinking about what materials can do.

Paper Summary

Methodology

The research team utilized a two-phase approach to develop and test these materials. First, they used computer modeling to design structures based on crystal lattice patterns, translating these natural arrangements into larger interlocking components. For manufacturing, they employed two distinct methods: conventional 3D printing with acrylic polymers, nylon, and metals for larger samples (about 2 inches across), and precise laser-based techniques called two-photon lithography for microscopic versions. The researchers systematically tested the materials using compression tests, shear force applications, and rheological measurements to understand their behavior under different conditions. Each test was repeated with varying forces and speeds to map out the materials’ full range of responses.

Results

The materials demonstrated several groundbreaking properties. They showed the ability to transition smoothly between fluid-like and solid-like states depending on the applied forces. Under gentle pressure, they exhibited minimal resistance, similar to a liquid. However, when subjected to sudden forces, they would rapidly become rigid. At the microscale, the materials rapidly expand and contract in response to electrostatic charges, reverting to their original shape once the charge is removed. Different designs showed varying levels of energy absorption and shape recovery, with some configurations performing better under compression while others excelled at handling shear forces.

Limitations

While the research demonstrates promising results, several limitations need to be addressed. The current manufacturing process is complex and time-consuming, particularly for microscopic versions, making mass production challenging with existing technology. The durability of these materials under repeated use still needs long-term testing. Additionally, while the materials can be made from various substances, finding the optimal material combinations for specific applications remains a challenge. The cost of production currently limits practical applications, though this may improve as manufacturing techniques advance.

Discussion and Takeaways

This research represents a significant breakthrough in materials science, introducing a new class of materials that bridges the gap between granular and crystalline matter. The ability to design materials that can change their behavior based on external stimuli opens up possibilities in various fields, from protective equipment to medical devices. The scalability of these materials from macro to micro sizes, while maintaining their core properties, is particularly significant. The research also establishes a framework for designing similar materials with different properties, potentially leading to a whole new field of engineered materials.

Funding and Disclosures

The research was supported by multiple organizations, including the Army Research Office and the Gary Clinard Innovation Fund. Additional support came from Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory and the U.S. Department of Energy. The High-Performance Computing Center at Caltech provided computational resources essential for the modeling and design phase of the research. The researchers reported no conflicts of interest.

Publication Information

This research was published in Science (Volume 387, pages 269-277) on January 17, 2025, with the title “3D polycatenated architected materials.” The authors include Wenjie Zhou, Sujeeka Nadarajah, Liuchi Li, Anna Guell Izard, Hujie Yan, Aashutosh K. Prachet, Payal Patel, Xiaoxing Xia, and Chiara Daraio from Caltech, Princeton University, and Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory. The paper underwent peer review and was accepted for publication on November 11, 2024.

About StudyFinds Analysis

Called "brilliant," "fantastic," and "spot on" by scientists and researchers, our acclaimed StudyFinds Analysis articles are created using an exclusive AI-based model with complete human oversight by the StudyFinds Editorial Team. For these articles, we use an unparalleled LLM process across multiple systems to analyze entire journal papers, extract data, and create accurate, accessible content. Our writing and editing team proofreads and polishes each and every article before publishing. With recent studies showing that artificial intelligence can interpret scientific research as well as (or even better) than field experts and specialists, StudyFinds was among the earliest to adopt and test this technology before approving its widespread use on our site. We stand by our practice and continuously update our processes to ensure the very highest level of accuracy. Read our AI Policy (link below) for more information.

Our Editorial Process

StudyFinds publishes digestible, agenda-free, transparent research summaries that are intended to inform the reader as well as stir civil, educated debate. We do not agree nor disagree with any of the studies we post, rather, we encourage our readers to debate the veracity of the findings themselves. All articles published on StudyFinds are vetted by our editors prior to publication and include links back to the source or corresponding journal article, if possible.

Our Editorial Team

Steve Fink

Editor-in-Chief

John Anderer

Associate Editor

Leave a Comment