(Credit: Photo by voronaman on Shutterstock)
In a Nutshell
- A study of more than 10,000 people found no real difference in overall abdominal muscle size between those with low back pain and those without it.
- People with low back pain had a slightly lower muscle-to-fat ratio than matched people without back pain, though the effect was small.
- Researchers used an AI tool to pull body composition data from CT scans patients had already gotten for other medical reasons, making this one of the largest imaging studies of back pain ever conducted.
People diagnosed with low back pain do not have smaller abdominal or back muscles than people without the diagnosis, according to a study of more than 10,000 patients, the largest of its kind. That result runs counter to a long-held belief that people with back pain tend to carry smaller core muscles, though it doesn’t resolve whether weak muscles contribute to pain.
Researchers at Stanford University, writing in the journal PLOS Digital Health, used an AI tool to measure muscle and fat on abdominal CT scans that patients had already received during routine hospital visits, rather than recruiting new volunteers for a costly, years-long study. Starting with a pool of 23,508 patients, the team built a core group of 10,835 people to map out normal patterns of muscle and fat across different ages and body sizes. They then compared 2,622 patients diagnosed with low back pain against 2,577 carefully matched people without that diagnosis.
That comparison muddies the simple “weak muscles cause back pain” story. Overall waist muscle size was nearly identical between the two groups, and fat distribution around internal organs versus just under the skin showed no difference. The one difference that turned up was small: people with low back pain had a slightly lower muscle-to-total-abdominal-fat ratio than the comparison group. That gap was statistically real but tiny in practical terms, meaning muscle size itself did not separate the two groups, even though the balance between muscle and surrounding fat did, just barely.
How AI Helped Researchers Study Muscle Size and Back Pain
Rather than scheduling new imaging appointments, the research team worked with scans collected during routine care at a single hospital system between 2013 and 2018. An AI tool scanned a single cross-section of each image near the lower spine, automatically measuring the area occupied by muscle, the fat surrounding internal organs, and the fat just under the skin.
Patients with a history of cancer were excluded, along with anyone missing basic health information or whose weight relative to height fell at extreme ends of the scale. That left 10,835 people for the main analysis, more than 6,000 of them women, with a midpoint age of around 51. Using electronic health records, the team then identified 2,622 patients diagnosed with low back pain and built a comparison group of 2,577 people without that diagnosis, matched by age, sex, and body size so the two groups looked as similar as possible on paper.
What the Data Showed About Muscle Size and Back Pain
Before drawing conclusions about back pain, the researchers checked whether their AI measurements matched well-established facts about aging bodies. They did. Muscle shrank with age at rates consistent with earlier research, roughly five to ten percent per decade in older age groups, and the balance of fat shifted toward the organs as people got older in both men and women. That match gave the team confidence that scans collected for unrelated reasons could still produce trustworthy, large-scale health data.
With that groundwork in place, the back pain comparison produced a clear pattern. Muscle size, adjusted for body size, showed no meaningful difference between the low-back-pain group and the matched comparison group. Organ fat versus skin fat also looked the same across both groups. Only the muscle-to-total-abdominal-fat ratio differed, and even that gap was real only statistically. Researchers measured the effect at just 0.004, meaning a back pain diagnosis accounted for very little of the variation in muscle-to-fat ratio compared with factors such as sex and body size.
Why This Matters for People With Back Pain
Physical therapy for low back pain has long centered on building core strength, partly on the assumption that people in pain have smaller or weaker trunk muscles. Drawing on a far larger sample than earlier work, the study’s authors say their results undercut that assumption. One earlier study using the UK Biobank did find smaller muscles in people with back pain, but only in the individual muscles running alongside the spine, not the overall bulk measured here. Read together, the two studies suggest the real link between muscle and back pain may lie in those specific spinal muscles rather than in how much total muscle a person carries.
Researchers involved in the work say future studies should look more closely at how well muscles coordinate and fire during movement, rather than focusing only on muscle size. That slightly lower muscle-to-fat ratio in the back pain group also raises another question worth chasing: whether the balance between fat and muscle, rather than muscle size alone, matters for how the back handles physical strain over time.
None of this proves muscle has no part in back pain, and the study can’t say whether a low muscle-to-fat ratio causes pain or simply co-occurs with it, since the data were collected at a single point in time rather than tracked over years. But the scale of this comparison, built from real hospital data rather than a small recruited sample, is hard to dismiss. People with low back pain who have been told their muscles are simply too weak may be getting an oversimplified explanation. The muscle is often there. What differs, if anything, seems more subtle than size.
Back pain remains one of the most common reasons people miss work or see a doctor, and the instinct to blame weak muscles makes sense given how often it gets repeated in waiting rooms and physical therapy offices. This research, built on one of the largest imaging comparisons of its kind, indicates that instinct doesn’t hold up once muscle size is measured directly and compared at scale. The honest takeaway isn’t that muscle has nothing to do with back pain, but that muscle bulk isn’t the dividing line many assumed it was. The search for real answers needs to look elsewhere.
Disclaimer: This was an observational, cross-sectional study, meaning it measured body composition at a single point in time and cannot prove that muscle size or the muscle-to-fat ratio causes, prevents, or results from low back pain. The study also identified back pain through medical diagnosis codes rather than direct assessments of pain severity or duration, and it measured muscle at one abdominal level rather than the individual muscles closest to the spine.
Paper Notes
Limitations
Study authors caution that their control group came from routine hospital patients rather than a certifiably “healthy” population, since people getting CT scans often have some underlying medical reason for the imaging. Back pain diagnoses were identified using standardized medical billing codes, which do not capture how severe or long-lasting a person’s pain was and may lump different types of back pain under one umbrella. The dataset also lacked reliable information on lifestyle factors such as physical activity levels, inflammation, or physical therapy use, any of which could influence body composition independent of back pain. Finally, because the scans were originally taken for other medical purposes rather than to study the spine specifically, the analysis measured bulk tissue at a single abdominal level rather than individual muscles, so the findings may not apply directly to muscle groups next to the spine.
Funding and Disclosures
Funding came from National Institutes of Health grants R01 HL167974, R01 AR077604, R01 EB002524, R01 AR079431, and P50HD118632. The paper states the funders played no role in the study’s design, data collection, analysis, interpretation, or manuscript writing. Several authors disclosed financial ties to medical technology and imaging companies, including research support, consulting arrangements, and equity stakes; one author, Louis Blankemeier, is currently employed by an imaging company but completed all work on this study as a Stanford student. Four authors, Kathryn R. Marusich, Robert D. Boutin, Garry E. Gold, and Scott L. Delp, declared no competing interests.
Publication Details
Paper Title: “Deep learning reveals relationships between muscle and adipose tissue and their associations with age, body mass index, and low back pain: A cross-sectional study in 10,835 subjects”
Authors: Kathryn R. Marusich, Anthony A. Gatti, Louis Blankemeier, Robert D. Boutin, Matthew Smuck, Garry E. Gold, Scott L. Delp, and Akshay S. Chaudhari, all affiliated with Stanford University. Kathryn R. Marusich is the corresponding author ([email protected]).
Journal: PLOS Digital Health, volume 5, issue 11 (2026), article e0001788







