
(Photo by Unsplash+ in collaboration with Getty Images)
Children Already Expect Girls to Give Up More for Others
In A Nutshell
- Children ages 5 to 8 and adults tended to expect girls, more than boys, to take on jobs that cost the helper something.
- Boys and men showed no lean toward girls for everyday helping, only when the helper had to give something up.
- Beliefs that girls are kinder did not fully explain the pattern.
- The study measured expectations, not behavior, so it cannot show these beliefs cause girls to do more extra work later.
Ask a classroom for one volunteer to skip recess and set up chairs for an assembly, and children ages 5 to 8 tend to expect that volunteer to be a girl, according to a new study in Developmental Science. Adults tend to expect the same, especially when the job costs the helper something.
Researchers from Princeton University, the University of Amsterdam and New York University wanted to know why women take on more thankless extra work than men, whether that means taking notes nobody else wants to take or organizing the holiday gathering. The team asked whether people expect girls to handle jobs like these long before anyone understands paychecks or promotions. Testing 192 children and 192 adults, they found the answer was yes.
Boys and men added a twist. In everyday helping, they saw boys and girls as equally likely to step up. Sacrifice changed that.
Gender Stereotypes About Sacrifice Surfaced in Six School Stories
Each participant heard or read six short stories about kids at school. Two featured a child helping a classmate in need, such as one who fell off a swing. Two featured a child pitching in for the group at no cost, such as when friends were home sick and recess held no appeal anyway. Two featured a child pitching in at a real cost, such as setting up materials for a class project instead of playing outside with friends. Each of the four group tasks appeared in costly and no-cost versions, though no one saw the same task twice.
After each story, participants looked at a cartoon picture of four girls and four boys and picked whether one of the girls or one of the boys helped. They then said how sure they were. Nobody could say the two were equally likely, so every response named a boy or a girl, and the researchers averaged the answers to see which way each group leaned. Adults read the stories on their own, while an experimenter read them aloud to children. Adults were included because their expectations of children may shape how girls and boys are treated.
A total of 192 children took part, ages 5 to 8, averaging 7 years old, half girls and half boys. Among the families that reported race and ethnicity, about two-thirds of the children were White, and most of the rest were Asian or multiracial. Another 192 adults took part, about half recruited from a university (average age about 20) and half through the online research platform Prolific (average age about 35). More than half were women, nearly half were White and 38% were Asian.
Boys and Men Expected Girls to Sacrifice Only for Costly Tasks
Girls and women expected a girl to be the helper in all three kinds of stories, costly or not. That fits a tendency to favor one’s own gender, and a broad belief that girls are more caring may add to it. Boys and men differed. For helping a classmate and for no-cost favors, they showed no lean toward either gender. Answers shifted toward girls only when the helper had to give up something wanted. That lean was small, but it was unlikely to be a fluke.
Gender Stereotypes Went Beyond Seeing Girls as Kind
Participants also answered six questions about whether boys or girls care more about things like being kind, being friendly and thinking about other people’s feelings. People who held those beliefs more strongly were more likely to expect girls to make costly sacrifices, but the beliefs did not fully explain it. Even after accounting for them, both male and female participants still expected girls over boys to take on costly jobs.
Prior research has found that women are disproportionately expected to accept “non-promotable” tasks, meaning work that keeps a team running but does little to advance a career. The authors also point to earlier research linking a habit of putting others’ needs ahead of one’s own to poorer well-being.
Children Ages 5 to 8 Held the Same Expectation as Adults
Children’s answers matched adults’, and the pattern did not grow stronger between ages 5 and 8. Earlier research from the same lead author offers a clue about timing. In a study of 6- to 9-year-olds, girls became more likely than boys to volunteer for this kind of work by around age 9, even though children said girls and boys should do it equally. Expectations, then, may arrive years before the behavior, raising the possibility that they help produce it.
Where children pick up the expectation is also unknown. The authors call watching who does the work at home a plausible source, noting that earlier research found children as young as 3 correctly report that their mothers do most household labor. Children who see that day after day could absorb the idea that girls are the ones who pick up the slack.
Whether these expectations push girls toward extra work or simply mirror what children already see remains unproven. Still, teachers and parents who need a volunteer can start by noticing which child they ask first.
Disclaimer: This article summarizes a published scientific study for a general audience and is not medical, psychological or professional advice. Findings from a single study reflect the specific participants and methods described and may not apply to every person or situation. Anyone with concerns should consult a qualified professional.
Paper Notes
Limitations
This study measured what children and adults expect, not what girls and boys actually do, so it cannot show that early expectations cause later differences in who takes on extra work. Participants responded to short school stories that stated outright whether a task was costly, while real-life costs are often harder to judge. Cost and group benefit were not tested separately, which leaves open whether boys and men would also expect girls to make costly sacrifices that help a single person. The no-cost stories described helpers as bored, which may have given them a small personal benefit, and one helping story involved a child who fell off a swing, a rescue-style situation that past research ties more to men and that may have pulled answers toward boys. The two helping stories always came last, so earlier stories could have shaped answers to them, though switching the order of the costly and no-cost stories did not change the main result.
When children were analyzed alone, the key pattern just missed the researchers’ strict cutoff for statistical significance, while it cleared the cutoff in adults. Results were combined across children and adults because the pattern did not differ by age group. Children averaged 7 years old, most were White among those whose race was reported, and adults came from a university and an online research platform. Nonbinary participants (one child and five adults) could not be included in the analyses, and 37 children and 19 adults were excluded, mostly for failing comprehension checks. The design also could not examine whether race, ethnicity or culture changes the pattern.
Funding and Disclosures
New York University supported the research. The authors declared no conflicts of interest, and the study received ethics approval from New York University’s Institutional Review Board. Data and analysis scripts are publicly available on the Open Science Framework.
Publication Details
Sophie H. Arnold (Department of Psychology, Princeton University), Katharina Block (Department of Psychology, University of Amsterdam) and Andrei Cimpian (Department of Psychology, New York University) wrote “The Development of Gender Stereotypes About Service,” published in Developmental Science, volume 30 (2027), article e70298. The paper appeared online on November 5, 2026, after being received April 21, 2026 and accepted October 17, 2026. DOI: 10.1111/desc.70298. It is open access under a Creative Commons Attribution License. Correspondence: Sophie H. Arnold, [email protected].







