More Is Never Enough: College Students Face Record Pressure To Be Perfect

College Students Have Never Felt More Judged. A 35-Year Study Shows the Mental Health Cost.

For today’s college students, the pressure to be flawless has reached a point that would have seemed extreme to their parents. A new analysis spanning 35 years of data finds that perfectionism among college students has been rising and accelerating, with the sharpest surge arriving in the early 2000s and no sign of letting up. Published in Psychological Bulletin, the research makes a case that this is not simply a personality quirk of ambitious young people. It may represent a growing mental health concern at the population level.

Researchers at the London School of Economics and Political Science, York St John University, and the University of Toronto pooled data from 307 samples covering 82,939 college students in the United States, Canada, and the United Kingdom. The literature search extended through June 2025, making it one of the broadest looks at how perfectionism has shifted across college student populations over time. Students today are not only demanding more from themselves. They increasingly believe that everyone around them is demanding perfection from them too, while growing more anxious, indecisive, and prone to distress over mistakes.

What raises this beyond an interesting personality trend is what it means for mental health. As perfectionism rises, so too does concern about its well-documented links to depression and anxiety, and this research examined whether those links are holding.

Perfectionism Is Rising, and It Is Getting Worse

Perfectionism is not simply about having high standards. Psychologists identify different types. One is the internal drive to hold impossibly high standards, being one’s own harshest critic. Another, and perhaps more troubling, is the belief that other people, parents, professors, society, are constantly scrutinizing and expecting nothing less than perfection. Both types have been climbing steadily for decades, but the outward-facing kind, the feeling of being constantly judged by others, took a particularly sharp turn upward starting around the early 2000s.

Researchers also tracked how much students worry about making mistakes and how often they second-guess whether a task was done correctly. Both rose in a straight, unbroken line. Worry about making mistakes showed the single largest increase of any dimension in the study, climbing at nearly four times the rate of personal standards.

In the researchers’ own framing, students are increasingly perceiving “others as excessively demanding while becoming more demanding of themselves, accompanied by growing indecisiveness, uncertainty, and sensitivity about making mistakes.” Today’s college students feel like they’re running a race in which the finish line keeps moving, the judges are everywhere, and stumbling is simply not an option.

How Researchers Tracked Perfectionism Across 35 Years

To detect trends across decades, the research team combined results from hundreds of separate studies collected at different points in time, like assembling puzzle pieces from dozens of researchers to see what the full picture looks like.

After searching multiple academic databases and contacting study authors directly, the team gathered data collected between January 1989 and June 2025. After screening thousands of studies, they landed on 297 studies producing 307 usable samples. Those samples covered 82,939 college students, 71% of whom were female, with an average age of just over 20. Students came from American, Canadian, and British universities.

To look for explanations, the team brought in economic data. They examined whether changes in income inequality, the gap between the wealthiest and the rest, and changes in economic output per person were connected to shifts in perfectionism scores. Rising inequality was associated with steeper increases in the more anxiety-driven, self-critical form of perfectionism. Declining economic output per person was associated with higher levels of the achievement-driven, standard-setting form. These are associations, not proven causes, but when societies become more unequal or economically strained, young people appear to feel the squeeze in the form of intensified perfectionism.

Pandemic Pressures and What the Data Shows

Although the study includes recent data, it was not designed to isolate the pandemic’s effect on perfectionism. As contextual background, the authors cite a large-scale survey of more than 10,000 U.S. college students that found achievement stress was far higher partway through the pandemic than at the outset. Some 57% of students reported their parents’ expectations hadn’t dropped, while 34% said expectations had actually increased. Whether the pandemic accelerated the longer-term trend is not something the data can directly establish.

Against that backdrop, the team also examined whether perfectionism’s long-established ties to depression and anxiety had shifted over the full 35 years. If the trait had simply become normalized, the public health picture might look less dire. That is not what they found. Perfectionism’s association with both depression and anxiety stayed consistent across all 35 years. That stability means each new wave of college students that becomes more perfectionistic is, as a group, more likely to fall into patterns linked with depression and anxiety, a trend researchers say is becoming a public health problem.

More Than a Personal Problem

It would be easy to view relentlessly high self-standards as just a personality trait, ambitious, maybe neurotic, but ultimately a private matter. This research argues otherwise. The scale of the shift, the economic and social forces tied to it, and the stable link to depression and anxiety point to something much larger than individual psychology. Addressing the youth mental health crisis, the researchers conclude, will require not just therapy or personal coping strategies, but also reckoning with the cultural and economic conditions that have been steadily raising the stakes for young people for more than three decades.

---

Disclaimer: This article is based on a published, peer-reviewed study. Findings reflect statistical associations among college students in the United States, Canada, and the United Kingdom and do not establish direct causation. If you or someone you know is struggling with perfectionism or mental health, please seek support from a qualified professional.

---